Sins of the Father: How Padre Alberto Cutié could be good PR for Catholic Church

Padre Alberto by Tiempo Honduras. 2009

In a time when Roman Catholic priests are being moved from parish to parish because of child molestation charges rather than excommunicated, Padre Alberto Cutié could be the church’s saving grace.

With almost celebrity status in the realm of The Virgin, Alberto Cutié is one of the most recognizable faces in the Hispanic religious community. Ordained as a Catholic priest for the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Miami in 1995, Cutié was the first Catholic priest to have his own television and radio programs. He is a regular columnist in various newspapers across Latin America and the United States. He is a regular on Telemundo, reaching millions of households throughout the United States, Canada, Spain and Latin America for EWTN en español. Think of him as the Spanish version of Joel Osteen. Yes, we are talking about that type of religious super-stardom.

This is the man who officiated at Celia Cruz’s funeral mass in Miami in July 2003 and who Newsweek dubs “Father Oprah.”

So why would the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Miami (along with the other institutions he is affiliated with) remove his programs from the air and bar him from saying mass?

TVnotas can be thanked for publishing photographs of the Padre apparently kissing a woman and engaging in other compromising activities.

While it is understandable that many Catholics probably don’t agree with Cutié’s actions, there will be more than just a few snickers and sneers at church’s handling of the situation. These punishments are excessive considering the actions of other Roman Catholic priests in recent years. The whole thing reeks of doctrinal intolerance and hypocrisy against a man who has done nothing but promote the church while some of his counterparts were embezzling money and sexually abusing children.

But let’s not digress from the point. Personal opinions aside, Padre Alberto Cutié could be good PR for the Roman Catholic Church:

  • The Roman Catholic Church  does have priests (converted members of the Anglican, Episcopal and alike) who are married with children, and the church’s Deacons are also allowed to marry.

Canon law allows Deacons to marry, so why not priests? Pope Paul VI restored the diaconate/deaconate in 1967 reaffirming the allowance for Deacons (read .pdf here) to engage in marriage. It is not canon law that priests cannot marry, just a tradition.  So for a man who is the poster-face for the Hispanic community (the largest minority in the United States), it is not too much to ask for the church to reinstate him. This would save the Church the shame of hypocrisy by choosing the freedom of the child molesters (regardless of whether there is a shortage of priests) over a man who simply did what human nature dictates. Furthermore, there are Catholic priests who are married with children.

  • He is not doing drugs, he is not drinking himself into a stupor; the man is just asking to have the opportunity to be in love.

That is not very much to ask for. Punishing someone for wanting the freedom to love is a tale as old as time: Romeo and Juliet, Anthony and Cleopatra, The Little Mermaid and Prince Eric — but still, isn’t that what Jackie DeShannon preaches about: “What the world needs now is love, sweet love”? Call it what you will, but any resurgence of the ideals of the Flower Children promoting harmony for something rooted in pureness sounds pretty good in my book.

While loyalty is a very important to Catholics, in order to keep the faith it’s understandable that anyone would switch ‘homes’ in order to continue preaching in peace. Should Padre Cutié move over the Episcopal Church, there would be a strike of considerable size against the Roman Catholic church for compelling him to go. Make no mistake, he has followers.  They love him enough to move with him wherever he goes.

From John Paul II apologizing for the Crusades to Benedict XVI apologizing — a little too late – about his Bavarian speech, the Vatican has not had a lot of positive PR lately, to say the least.

Questions?

  • How to rebuild a tarnished image?
  • Work with the unworkable?
  • Make it go in your favor?

Put a Little Love in Your Heart

–

Sasha Muradali runs the ‘Little Pink Book’ and ‘SashaHalima PR.’ She holds a B.S. in Public Relations and an M.A. in International Administration.

Copyright © 2009 SashaHalima PR. All rights reserved

Comments

  1. I personally have avoided reading all of the Padre Alberto drama.
    I don’t exactly agree that priests can’t marry. But if they choose to support that religion and its doctrines, then I do feel they are saying they shouldn’t marry too.

    My only question is… Is he in love with her or is it just lust?

  2. … from what I heard yesterday on Local10 Miami, he’s in love with her and they’ve been in a relationship for 2-years. But who really knows?

  3. As a Catholic,we were told that Priest arent allowed to get married, its part of what they “signed up” for when planning to become a Priest.
    I am only sorry that he saw it fit to continue to advise and preach while commiting this sin,its like being two faced.But we are all humans and fall short,but does that mean we should not be forgiven? If he is in love as they say he said and wants to continue this life then he should leave the Catholic Church and go over to the Episcopal, where its okay.
    My Prayers is that he will make the right decision with his life.

  4. Whether one agrees or not with the Roman Church’s unfounded belief that their priests should not marry, there is a question of deception on the part of Padre Alberto towards his followers, he was representing the Roman church yet not living what he preached about, how can we believe anything else from his lips? he should have resigned the minute he realized he could not live up to the tenets he represented.

  5. Karla Contreras says:

    I had to hear it in order to bealive it. Hypocricy… He used to defend the Catholic Church, I didn’t bealive a single word on not trying to hurt anyone. He just left us, since in the Epicospal will be able to get a check and have his girlfrind not catholic, a fake.

  6. very inspiring. i like your post. thanks for this. thanks for sharing your experience to us. good luck to you and keep up the good work.

  7. very inspiring. i like your post. thanks for this. thanks for sharing your experience to us. good luck to you and keep up the good work.

  8. very inspiring. i like your post. thanks for this. thanks for sharing your experience to us. good luck to you and keep up the good work.